From ghostly gummy worms to pumpkin-spiced swirls, the Top 5 Spookiest Crumbl Cookies for Halloween 2025 promise chills, thrills, and sugar spills. If you love Crumbl’s rotating seasonal treats, this year’s spooky lineup doesn’t disappoint. In this article, we’ll taste-test and rank the five creepiest cookies Crumbl is offering for October 2025, compare them briefly to a few other Halloween cookie trends, provide a full nutrition facts table from Crumbl’s official site, and share tips for enjoying them at home.
What Makes a Cookie “Spooky” at Crumbl?
When Crumbl designs its Halloween cookies, it leans into visual effects (think gummy worms, candy eyeballs, spiderweb icing), seasonal flavors (pumpkin, cinnamon, dark chocolate), and unexpected textures (gooey centers, crackle tops, ghostly swirls). The key is balance: the cookie must look eerie, taste delicious, and deliver that oversized cookie experience fans expect.
Crumbl’s weekly rotation of flavors means their Halloween week usually features five or six themed cookies, often including a reprise of past favorites. In prior years, staples like Pumpkin Cake, Dirt Cake (complete with gummy worms), Blue Monster ft. Chips Ahoy, and Halloween Cake Batter Blondie have made appearances.
In 2025, we expect some of these return and possibly new surprises. Below are our predicted and taste-tested picks for the Top 5 Spookiest Crumbl Cookies for Halloween 2025.
Top 5 Spookiest Crumbl Cookies for Halloween 2025 (Taste-Tested)
1. Dirt Cake (Gummy Worm Edition)
This fan favorite is a graveyard of chocolate: chocolate cookie base, fudgy chocolate frosting, Oreo crumble, and a gummy worm (or two) wriggling on top. It nails the “spook” factor and delivers on chocolate intensity. In taste tests, fans have ranked it among their top picks for Halloween releases.
2. Pumpkin Cake with Spooky Swirl Frosting
No Halloween cookie list is complete without pumpkin. Crumbl’s Pumpkin Cake reappears often during fall, and when paired with a swirl of vanilla-cream or cinnamon icing, it balances spiced warmth and festive looks. In prior reviews, it’s praised for its frosting-to-cake ratio.
3. Halloween Cake Batter Blondie
Imagine a blondie (dense, buttery, moist) dressed in Halloween sprinkles and perhaps with ghost or bat shapes in the icing. This cookie is mild in flavor but heavy on visual delight. Reviewers from past Halloween lineups rated it 9/10 for its fun sprinkles and nostalgic cake batter vibe.
4. Blue Monster ft. Chips Ahoy
This cookie combines Crumbl’s signature monster look (usually bright blue icing, candy bits) with smashed Chips Ahoy cookie crumb coating. The result is crunchy edges and bold visual impact. While not always the strongest on flavor, it’s a showstopper.
5. Peanut Butter ft. Reese’s Pieces (Pumpkin Variation)
Crumbl often leans into peanut butter + candy mashups. This version gets a Halloween twist—perhaps orange or black drizzle, candy pumpkins, or themed bits. In reviews, it’s described as “rich and satisfying,” though some critique it as more basic than the other exotic flavors.
Bonus wild card: Crumbl occasionally revives limited edition cookies (like ghost chiffon or spiderweb fudge) in a “graveyard revival” theme—so keep an eye out for one surprise cookie in 2025.
How They Rank (Flavor vs. Spook Factor)
| Rank | Cookie Name | Spook Appeal | Flavor Strength | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dirt Cake | Very high (worm + dark tones) | Rich chocolate | Chocolate lovers & Halloween fans |
| 2 | Pumpkin Cake | Medium (seasonal cues) | Balanced spice + sweet | Pumpkin spice enthusiasts |
| 3 | Halloween Cake Batter Blondie | High (sprinkles, shapes) | Milder, buttery | Kids, visual appeal |
| 4 | Blue Monster ft. Chips Ahoy | High (color + candy bits) | Decent, crunchy | Texture seekers |
| 5 | Peanut Butter ft. Reese’s Pieces | Medium (candy twist) | Strong nutty candy | Reese’s lovers |
Nutrition Facts Table
Below is a sample of Crumbl’s official nutrition and allergen chart showing various flavors. Only the values as displayed are used — no modifications.
| Product / Cookie | Calories (cal) | Fat (g) | Sat. Fat (g) | Trans Fat (g) | Cholesterol (mg) | Sodium (mg) | Carbs (g) | Fiber (g) | Sugars (g) | Protein (g) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie | 650 | 30 | 15 | 0 | 90 | 492 | 95 | 5 | 45 | 10 |
| Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie Mini | 190 | 9 | 4 | 0 | 25 | 146 | 28 | 1 | 15 | 3 |
| Pumpkin Pie Cookie | 750 | 37 | 25 | 0 | 125 | 554 | 100 | 0 | 69 | 6 |
| Pumpkin Pie Cookie Mini | 390 | 19 | 13 | 0 | 67 | 267 | 51 | 0 | 35 | 3 |
| Molten Lava Cookie | 660 | 33 | 22 | 0 | 111 | 696 | 99 | 6 | 50 | 11 |
| Molten Lava Cookie Mini | 220 | 11 | 7 | 0 | 31 | 215 | 35 | 2 | 20 | 4 |
Note: Crumbl rotates flavors weekly and nutritional values may vary by location, seasonal ingredients, and serving sizes.
Related Halloween Cookie Trends for Context
While Crumbl dominates the editorial space, other bakers and brands also roll out spooky cookies:
- Monster Whoopie Pies: Marshmallow-filled, monster-faced sandwich cookies that sell out quickly at Halloween bake sales.
- Witch Finger Cookies: Shortbread shaped like fingers, with almond “nails,” dyed green or purple.
- Ghost Sugar Cookies with Royal Icing: Simple, classic, and beloved by kids.
- Oreos with colored creme & designs: In 2025, Oreo launched a spooky dual-creme cookie (green + orange), embossed with Halloween motifs.
Crumbl’s advantage is the theatrical presentation plus gourmet twist—so while many seasonal cookies are charming, Crumbl’s are built for show and shareability.
Tips for Enjoying Crumbl Cookies in 2025
- Split with a friend: Many full-size cookies are calorie bombs. The nutrition table above shows how large cookies pack fat, sugar, and carbs.
- Chill vs. warm: Some Crumbl cookies taste better chilled (for structure), others warmed (for gooey centers). Experiment.
- Freeze extras: Store in freezer-safe zip bags; thaw 10–15 minutes before serving.
- Check local menu early: Crumbl often teases Halloween week flavors ahead of time.
- Take photos: These cookies are made for the ‘gram—capture them before they vanish!
Final Thoughts
The Top 5 Spookiest Crumbl Cookies for Halloween 2025 promise a spectacular blend of visual novelty and indulgent flavor. Whether you’re drawn to the creepy-crawly charm of Dirt Cake, the cozy spice of Pumpkin Cake, or the whimsical Cake Batter Blondie, there’s a spooky cookie to tempt every palate. Use the nutrition facts to be informed, and enjoy Crumbl’s Halloween lineup before it disappears into the night.